The proposed class action settlement in In re Collegiate Athlete NIL Litigation, publicly known as House v. NCAA, cannot stand. It discriminates against women athletes in violation of Title IX, replaces one illegal price-fixing agreement with another, and creates roster limits that are already depriving thousands of athletes of the chance to play college sports. It also flouts both the class action rules and the U.S. Constitution, which require that class members with conflicting interests—like the female and male athletes here—be represented by separate lawyers devoted to them.